Defending an Interpleader Action in Florida: What You Need to Know
Introduction
Interpleader actions are often misunderstood, yet they play a crucial role in resolving disputes over property or funds when multiple parties assert conflicting claims. In Florida, if you've been named as a defendant in an interpleader action, it's essential to understand your rights and how to effectively defend your interest. This blog will walk through what an interpleader is, how it's used, and key strategies for defending against it in Florida courts.
What Is an Interpleader Action?
An interpleader is a legal procedure that allows a neutral party—typically someone holding property or money (often called a "stakeholder")—to ask the court to resolve competing claims from two or more parties. Rather than risk paying or delivering the property to the wrong party and being sued again, the stakeholder “interpleads” the funds and lets the court decide who is entitled to them.
Florida recognizes both statutory interpleader under Fla. R. Civ. P. 1.240, and equitable interpleader under common law principles.
Common Examples of Interpleader Cases in Florida
-
Insurance disputes: where two or more claimants assert rights to the same life insurance policy.
-
Escrow disputes: in real estate closings where buyer and seller both demand the deposit.
-
Probate matters: when multiple heirs claim the right to the same inheritance.
What to Do If You’re Named in an Interpleader Action
If you’re one of the parties claiming entitlement to the disputed property or funds, defending an interpleader action means more than just showing up—it involves strategic legal action.
1. Understand the Nature of the Stakeholder's Role
The stakeholder must be neutral. If the stakeholder takes sides or asserts a claim beyond simply holding the property, it may undermine the interpleader and give you grounds to challenge the action.
Defense Tip: Examine whether the stakeholder is truly disinterested. If they’re not, you can argue the interpleader is improper.
2. Challenge the Basis for Interpleader (If Appropriate)
Not all interpleaders are valid. You may be able to challenge the action based on:
-
Lack of subject matter jurisdiction
-
Stakeholder's improper venue
-
Stakeholder failing to meet the procedural requirements under Fla. R. Civ. P. 1.240
-
The absence of adverse or conflicting claims
3. Assert Your Claim to the Funds or Property
Once the court determines the interpleader is proper and the stakeholder is discharged, the remaining claimants must litigate their entitlement.
Defense Tip: Gather contracts, emails, financial records, or any other documentation that supports your right to the funds or property.
4. Address Attorney’s Fees and Costs
Florida courts often allow stakeholders to recover reasonable attorney’s fees and costs from the interpleaded funds. You can oppose excessive or unreasonable fee requests, especially if the stakeholder was not entirely neutral or unnecessarily increased litigation.
Important Procedural Note
If the stakeholder is dismissed early in the case, the action continues as a normal civil lawsuit between the remaining parties. At this stage, it's crucial to treat the proceeding like any other civil claim—asserting counterclaims, conducting discovery, and potentially moving for summary judgment or trial.
Final Thoughts
Defending an interpleader action in Florida requires both procedural awareness and a strong substantive claim. Whether you're fighting over insurance proceeds, a real estate deposit, or other contested property, knowing your rights and the proper defenses can make all the difference in protecting your interests.
If you’ve been served in an interpleader case and aren’t sure what to do next, consult with a Florida litigation attorney who can guide you through the process.
Have you or someone you know been served with an interpleader action? Contact Florida Lawyer J.P. Gonzalez-Sirgo by dialing his direct number at (786) 272-5841, calling the main office at (305) 461-1095, or Toll Free at 1 (866) 71-CLAIM or email Miami Attorney Gonzalez-Sirgo directly at [email protected] or by text at (305) 929-8935.
